With the close of the 2011-2012 NHL regular season it is now time for a yearly tradition of mine: playoff prognostication! Every year for … well, ages … I’ve made my playoff predictions from round to round. It all started out when I was a member of the West Coast Hockey League dynasty pool and has continued on after I left. I challenge my friends and followers to post their own predictions as well to see how well we know our stuff. The rules are simple, for each series in each round pick the winning team and then justify your choice. So without further ado, here are the first round predictions:
Eastern Conference
New York Rangers (1) vs. Ottawa Senators (8) – New York in 5
The Senators have been a feel-good story all year long. Expected to finish 15th in the conference by many, they have surprised everyone by being one of the two Canadian teams in the playoffs. The Rangers, on the other hand, have been at or near the top of the league for most of the season. On paper this series looks like it will be a bit of a laugher, and it probably will be. The Rangers are a more complete team from top to bottom. Their goaltending is solid and their coach has them playing a team-first game blocking shots and tenaciously forechecking. The Senators will put up some fight, but in the end, it will be nowhere near enough so I’m saying the Rangers in 5 in what could likely be Daniel Alfredson’s swan song. The only hope that the Senators have is that their goaltending gets hot while the Rangers goes ice-cold.
Boston Bruins (2) vs. Washington Capitals (7) – Boston in 5
The defending Stanley Cup champions may have stumbled a bit in the stretch drive but it won’t matter. Their goaltending, defense, and size are things that the Capitals don’t have. Ignoring the boatloads of experience the Bruins have, they are just plain going to run over the Capitals. Ovechkin cannot do it all himself, even if he has been “saving himself for the playoffs”. Semin, while dangerous, is too much of an enigma to rely upon. Besides, how healthy are Backstrom and Green? No, Boston will be too big, to strong, too mean, and too good in net. Look for them to maybe give up an easy one in game 3 or 4 though.
Florida Panthers (3) vs. New Jersey Devils (6) – New Jersey in 6
While I think it’s great for the franchise that the Panthers made the playoffs for the first time in 7 years, let’s be real here: they were first place in a poor division. They had less points than the Devils who play in a more difficult division. I think Florida will have too much “happy to be here” feelings for them to really contend for a first round win. They have a balanced team but it won’t be enough to get past the Devils. Martin Brodeur and Ilya Kovalchuk will lead this team through the first round. The devils have more experience as an organization, they have one of the best goalies ever to play in the league, and they have a GM who could probably will them to win. The only area of the Devils’ game that I’m not sure about is their defense. Florida will put up a fight but in the end, it won’t be enough.
Pittsburgh Penguins (4) vs. Philadelphia Flyers (5) – Pittsburgh in 6
This is the marquee series of the first round in my opinion. Two teams that despise each other. This series will be nasty; fought in the trenches; no-holds-barred. In summary, it’s going to be great! Philadelphia is big and tough and will do everything they can to intimidate (if not actually beat the hell out of) the Penguins. They have good scoring and defense, but as usual, are a bit of an enigma in net. Who knows what Bryzgalov is going to do? Pittsburgh, on the other hand, has two of the most dynamic players in the game. There is no doubt that Crosby and Malkin can score and they will definitely give their opponents fits, but how ready is Crosby for playoff hockey? Can he take the extra banging and crashing that he will be subjected to? I think he will but that has to remain a major concern for him and the team. My biggest worry about the Penguins is that they give up a lot of scoring opportunities against. If Fluery isn’t near perfect, Pittsburgh’s high-flying offense may backfire. I don’t think the Penguins can shift to a lower-tempo, more conservative game if their goaltending goes south. I don’t see it happening, though, so I think Pittsburgh’s offense will (barely) get them past Philly’s size and strength.
Western Conference
St. Louis Blues (2) vs. San Jose Sharks (7) – St. Louis in 5
Just give Ken Hitchcock the Jack Adams award now. The turnaround he’s engineered in St. Louis is amazing. He has the Blues buying into a great system and he has oodles of young talent and some spectacular goaltending. What do the Sharks have? They limped into the playoffs again and their goaltending is questionable. No-show Joe (Thornton and now Pavelski) are not the answer in San Jose. Look for this to be a quick series. Unless the Sharks grow a backbone, they will be out in the first and then the great rebuild will begin. Big Joe and Little Joe will make an appearance here and there, but as has been their modus operandi all year, they will underperform and the Blues will overperform and that will be that. The Blues are too young to realize that they should be nervous at this point. This has the potential to be the most boring/uninteresting series in the first round.
Phoenix Coyotes (3) vs. Chicago Blackhawks (6) – Chicago in 6
With all the potential distraction and financial constraints the Coyotes have been surrounded by in the last few seasons, I am very impressed that they have made the playoffs again. Their strength has been their goaltending and I definitely feel that they aren’t simply going to be “happy to be here” this year. They have a balanced team but I don’t think they will have enough to take the Blackhawks. With Jonathan Toews out, however, there is a major hole in the offensive lineup and leadership group for the Blackhawks. How will that affect the team? Will their goaltending be good enough? There are some questions surrounding this year’s edition of the Blackhawks. I think the team has too much experience and a game that is overall suited to the playoffs so that will give them the edge. If they take the Coyotes too lightly or if their goaltending goes south, they could be in trouble. While I don’t think this will be a nasty series, the Coyotes will push Chicago but ultimately fall.
Nashville Predators (4) vs. Detroit Red Wings (5) – Detroit in 7
Much like the Penguins-Flyers series, this is definitely going to be a series to watch. While it won’t be the knock-down drag-em-out series that the Penguins and Flyers will play, it will be a long, grinding series. The Predators play that style naturally and the Wings can pretty much play any style they need to. Pekka Rinne gives Nashville a huge edge in net, but the Wings have simply been the best team in hockey for the last 20 years and were only slowed down this year due to injuries. If Detroit is healthy, look for their experience and puck-control game to edge out over the Predators. If the Wings are (or get) too banged up, they will get ground down by the Predators.
Vancouver Canucks (1) vs. Los Angeles Kings (8) – Vancouver in 6
Of all the teams Vancouver probably did not want to face, it would have been the Kings. With their outstanding goaltending and defensive system, the Kings are not what the goal-starved Canucks needed in their first round. Despite how the final few games went for the Canucks, there are still a lot of questions surrounding their ability to score. This year, however, there are fewer concerns with Vancouver’s goaltending. If Luongo doesn’t perform, there is little doubt that Cory Schneider will be put in and given a chance to run with things. That pressure is good for Luongo in my opinion. He can’t take a period or a game off. What will it take to get Kesler going? How about Daniel’s health and can they win without him? Is the defense deep enough? For Los Angeles, the ability to score has got to be their biggest concern. Despite their solid goaltending and team defense, you can’t win games unless you put the puck in the net. This is going to be a tricky series but I think the Canucks will be able to take their experience from last year and use it to help them though this series. Look for a few unsung heros from Vancouver, though. I think it will take the team a series before the big guns emerge. LA will be physical but their lack of offense will sink them in the end. The Canucks will be too experienced, too deep, and too capable.